Categories
Writing Portfolio

Non-traditional: The Effects of Exclusionary Attitudes on LBTQIA Americans

Sociologically speaking, a family is merely a group of people living together in one household that are connected by blood or law. While this is understandably a very broad definition, it would be fair to say that the American mindset towards what constitutes a family has traditionally been much narrower. The typical American ideal of the Nuclear family, which is a family consisting of a heterosexual couple and their children, has been perpetuated by popular culture since the end of the second World War. Unfortunately, the ever-growing population that exists outside of this supposedly commonplace archetype (such as LGBT families or single-parent families) are labeled as non-traditional. Labels like this, while harmless at first glance, creates a degree of separation between marginalized groups and the society that they belong to. Sadly, this sentiment is only amplified by the woefully inconsistent societal attitudes towards the mere existence of these groups. The resulting exclusionary atmosphere created by highlighting breaks from traditions and the perception of normality has a tendency to cause severe damage, both to the mental states of those outside the norm, and to the structure of families whose members do not conform to religious or legal standards.

It goes almost without saying that the United States has not always been kind to LGBT citizens. Despite the fact that this country is built upon the singular principle of providing equality for all, LGBT Americans only recently obtained equal marriage rights. While this victory is clearly symbolic of greater change to come in the future, the country’s broad spectrum of reactions to this change largely indicates that though the fight for equal rights is progressing steadily, the fight for acceptance shall be a far more difficult battle. Perhaps the greatest factor contributing to the lack of acceptance towards these people is a lack of understanding among the populace. For example, a poll conducted a few years ago determined that Americans believe that 25% of the U.S. population is LGBTQIA, when in actuality, the number comes to roughly 4% [1][4]. The major gap between public perception and reality in regards to that statistic demonstrates, generally speaking, how little people outside of the LGBTQIA demographics understand their peers within them, thus making it difficult for true empathy to be demonstrated, or for solutions to social problems to be created.


This culture of misunderstanding varies in terms of severity across the regions of the U.S., with each state possessing different political sentiments. While it would be unfair to treat the populace of each state as a political monolith, it would be quite the opposite to state that traditionally conservative states tend to have policies that are contrary to the needs of LGBT citizens and their families. Said legislation tends to use either religion or fear as a justification for withholding rights and conveniences that many take for granted. Acts like the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), passed in 1996, not only prevented same-sex couples from getting married, but also prevented said couples from benefitting from their partner’s insurance policies, or filing joint tax returns. While this act was declared unconstitutional in 2015, the fact that it stood for so long meant that LGBT Americans were extremely limited in their ability to form families, let alone thrive in them.


Although politics played into the issues LGBTQIA people families face each day in this country, it is the underlying cultures of our proverbial melting pot that fuel the implementation of the policies that oppress them. Religious motives, as stated before, are the most commonly cited reasoning for opposition to the formation of LGBT families. Though the current head of the Catholic church, Pope Francis, has taken a more accepting stance on LGBT issues, his organization has traditionally condemned all “Non-traditional” lifestyles. Considering the fact that 22% of the population [2] identifies as catholic, it would be a safe assumption that many families of this faith would be hesitant to accept LGBT family members. Other faiths in this country tend to have similar beliefs (namely Islam), and serve as just one of the many bastions of culture that has yet to accommodate for LGBT Americans.


Religion is a major facet of many American cultures, causing many to adopt attitudes that they wouldn’t have otherwise held. However, religion alone cannot account for the cultural push towards heteronormativity. Heteronormativity is the belief (comparable to ethnocentrism) that heterosexuality is the default or correct orientation, and some subcultures in America are built upon this belief. African-American culture in particular struggles with homophobia and heteronormativity, strengthening stigmas towards the LGBT members of the community. These stigmas, while regularly faced by LGBTQIA Americans in general, are especially harmful to Black men, who are at a disproportionately high risk for HIV [3]. It is likely due to the highly religious nature of said community that LGBT issues are largely ignored, if not outright frowned upon; this leads to more closeted LGBT Blacks, and worse yet, creates a dangerous climate for them to live in (especially for Transgender black Americans).

Perhaps the most devastating issue for young LGBTQIA Americans is Parental rejection. Parental rejection is the result of social stigmas outweighing a parent’s affection for their child, causing them to refuse to accept their child when they come out of the proverbial closet. Oftentimes, this rejection ends with the parent outright throwing the child out of their home.

Many of these young people have alternate familial connections willing to take them in, and unfortunately, many do not. Of the thousands of homeless youth that roam American streets, 40% of them are LGBTQIA. Dreadful as that statistic is, it allows us to directly correlate parental rejection with the plight faced by these young adults. Suicide rates are several times higher among LGBT (especially transgender) Americans than among those who are heterosexual/cisgender. The fact that gender fluidity (and/or any concept outside of traditional cisgender values) exists wholly apart from the belief systems and knowledge of many only exacerbates this issue, as there are few avenues for treatment, and a lack of understanding or tolerance causes many parents to reject their LGBT children and thus feed directly into the increased risks of suicide, drug addiction, and potential HIV infection (which is a major part of the active anti-LGBT stigma, thus creating a self-fulfilling prophecy).


As these problems grow increasingly prevalent, it becomes increasingly necessary for us as a society to implement short-term and long-term solutions. To start, our current laws define child abuse and endangerment as malnutrition, verbal abuse, and physical abuse. As a result of this wording, it is essentially legal for parents to kick their children out of their homes, thus sending them to a (likely) cruel fate. By broadening the definition of abuse/endangerment to include leaving them destitute, we can criminalize this kind of abuse, and hopefully lessen its prevalence and impact. Beyond that, it is imperative that we place more federal funding into creating/maintaining LGBT centers. Equipping these organizations with proper grants and supplies will help to offset the rates of drug use, sex work, and HIV infection among homeless youth, since they would have free accommodations with little to no strings attached. Non-traditional is considered by many to be an apt term to use when referring to LGBTQIA Americans; however, in their struggle to survive and thrive both on their own and in family units, their ability to overcome adversity is about as traditionally American as it gets.

References

[1] Newport, F. (2016, May 21). Americans Greatly Overestimate Percent Gay, Lesbian in U.S. Retrieved May 22, 2016, from http://www.gallup.com/poll/183383/americans-greatly-overestimate-percent-gay-lesbian.aspx

[2] Lipka, M. (2015, September 14). A closer look at Catholic America. Retrieved May 22, 2016, from http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/09/14/a-closer-look-at-catholic-america/


[3] Balaji, A. B., Oster, A. M., Viall, A. H., Heffelfinger, J. D., Mena, L. A., & Toledo, C. A. (2012). Role Flexing: How Community, Religion, and Family Shape the Experiences of Young Black Men Who Have Sex with Men. AIDS Patient Care and STDs, 26(12), 730-737. doi:10.1089/apc.2012.0177


[4] Gates, G. J. (2011, April). How Many People are Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender? Retrieved May 22, 2016, from http://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/research/census-lgbt-demographics-studies/how-many-people-are-lesbian-gay-bisexual-and-transgender/